.

So You Wanna’ Make Change? Then Let’s Be Frenemies

We don't make change by talking to our friends, but by talking to our "enemies".

Before you read past this sentence, how ‘bout a quick assignment for old times’ sake; jot down the 5 most powerful people you can think of.  Go ahead.  I’ll wait… 

…now, take a look at your list. I’m less interested in who you put so much as what it says about your personal definition of power. Are they, for example, athletes? Politicians? All men? All Americans? All famous? Your mother?

Your list will undoubtedly contain your values as well as your prejudices.  Don’t feel judged.  Remember, “I don’t know you.” But I know me, and I know that my own predispositions and presumptions will filter their way into this space which is supposed to be an open forum for ideas and conversations. 

So, rather than you trying to figure out whether I’m the kind of person you will want to befriend or befight, let’s cut to the chase and not pretend that any of us are objective.  Objectivity is Dead.  Long live Subjectivity. 

Below are listed (in no particular order) my most egregious offenses and affections...  

1. I love youth(fullness).  Rather than looking at youth as the “leaders of tomorrow,” I believe they are infinitely powerful today and that adults need to shift their definition of ageism to include the disregard and disrespect that young people (throughout the world) endure from older generations. I have found the youth in my life to quite often be more honest, more open to change, more hilarious, more creative than the majority of their adult counterparts.  As a wise signature intern said today, “I’m always afraid when I become an adult, my teenage sense of humor will expire.”  Me, too.      

2.  I’m a progressive, not a liberal.  For those of you who equate the two, wrap your mind around these paradoxical pairings: I am a public servant ambivalent about unions; I support entitlements and fiscal responsibility; I am pro-military but antiwar; I believe vegetarianism will help save the planet, but I love bacon; I am an English teacher who is "doing good" not "doing well."  Progressivism, in my opinion, is about anticipating future trends and advocating policies and positions that will remain relevant 20, 30, 100 years into the future.

3.  I relish copyright infringement and welcome it in others.  Poach my wisdom and absurdity. I will give credit where I can remember to do so.  But, like most teachers, I feel a perk of being a public servant is guilt-free Xerox privileges. I offset this piracy by holding with an open-hand all my original ideas, quotations, lesson plans, worksheets, etc. Rather than attempting to profit from my creative endeavors, I will store for myself treasures in heaven/nirvana/my Facebook feed.

4.  My children are strong, goodlooking, and above average. Will I find ways to incorporate pictures and anecdotes about my two-year-old twins?  Yes.  Should you judge me?  If it makes you feel better.

5.  The road to hell is paved with convergent thinking.  Too often we adults equate maturity with complacency or cynicism. Subsequently, we lose our willingness to believe in change. Practice this Madlib with me now: The unexamined (fill in the noun) is not worth (fill in verb ending in “ing”).  The unexamined job is not worth doing. The unexamined lesson is not worth learning. The unexamined Ugg is not worth wearing.  Now YOU try.  Leave me some divergent thinking in the comment section below.

6.    I reserve the right to be wrong.  I call this my “there is no permanent self” and “Why I love flip flops and flip floppers” clause. Inevitably I will say something that is either, a) poorly worded and therefore misconstrued or, b) poorly thought out and therefore justly criticized.  Part of both learning and character development is about strategic risk taking that leads to a refined and renewed outlook on life. As a wise nun once quipped, “Anything worth doing is worth doing poorly.”

7.  I love people who push back. While I have other biases, the good news is I try to surround myself with people bold enough to confront me on my blind spots. While some people seem to take comfort from their prejudices, I distrust mine and feel that if I just had more information I would happily be able to surrender them.

And because honesty loves company, I would encourage my fellow teachers and parents (and all adults, really) to practice this with the young people in your lives.  Being a youth is a practice in embracing or suppressing one’s authenticity.  Whether a young person becomes or undoes themselves is largely determined by what they see the adults they admire doing…the adults in their “top 5.”

So whether you share or abhor my biases, tell me about it.  We do not make change by talking to our friends.  We make change by talking to our enemies.

So, what do you say? If we can’t be friends, let’s be frenemies.

Barbara Dziedzic is the lead teacher for Arundel High School's Community Development and Global Citizenship Signature Program. 

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Lea Hurt January 13, 2013 at 09:47 PM
Yes.
McGibblets January 15, 2013 at 12:12 PM
"Progressivism, in my opinion, is about anticipating future trends and advocating policies and positions that will remain relevant 20, 30, 100 years into the future." Sounds more like speculative legislating, which can lead to devastating results. "I am pro-military but antiwar" So you support the troops as long as they do nothing? "I am a public servant ambivalent about unions" By servant do you mean you serve the public free of charge? Ambivalent about unions? Are you indifferent in regards to them or you simply cannot decide whether you support them or not? "I believe vegetarianism will help save the planet" What brings you to this belief? Just curious....
Chris W January 16, 2013 at 12:01 AM
Yes, but the one that makes me chuckle is "I support entitlements and fiscal responsibility". So you support entitlements, but not the tax collection needed to fund them? That's a big part of the problem we have with debt in this country. People support entitlements, until their taxes go up. People support tax cuts until THEIR program gets cut. Then they wail about how much other people pay because they do not have the courage of their convictions. It's easy to spend other peoples money.
Barbara Dziedzic January 16, 2013 at 08:53 PM
Thanks for the "Push Back." 1) Progressive in the sense of expecting and aligning ourselves with long term trends. I consider this a pragmatic rather than ethical choice. I think both conservatives and liberals can be progressives. 2) "Pro-military but anti-war" is a phrase I picked up from Captain Paul K. Chappell, whose book “Peaceful Revolution” outlines this concept. You can visit his website: http://www.paulkchappell.com/ . This is also in keeping with “SMART POWER” which seeks a more well balanced partnership between diplomatic, military, and civilian forces. Additionally, I’m curious how those members of our community who are in the military feel about the characterization that when they are not at war they are “doing nothing.” 3) “Public Service” as in those professions that make up “civil society.” My ambivalence is because while I believe the right to organize is an essential to democratic society I don’t feel the same way about tenure. I have enough to say about this for 10 blog posts. More to come. 4) Meat has become the rule rather than the exception and this, from a strictly pragmatic viewpoint, is a less efficient way to produce food. Why grow the grain to feed to the pig to feed to the human? I mean, the obvious answer is “Because bacon tastes better than bread.” Yadda, yadda, green house gasses from the methane that cows produce, yadda yadda, unsustainable fishing practices, yadda… Thanks (wo)man! Are we frenemies yet?
Tommy Warshaw III January 17, 2013 at 12:07 PM
I think, unfortunately people are going to misunderstand the "pro-military, but anti-war" statement. I know exactly what you mean though. There is this fallacy that somehow you need to support the constant engagement of our troops or you don't support them at all. With the exception of a few overly aggressive folks, nobody desires peace more than those serving in the military. Why? Because when the crap hits the fan, it is we who are put in harms way. We do it without question when we have to, but that does not mean we necessarily want war. If I never have to see another flag-draped coffin of a fallen brother or sister, I'd be a happy man. I heard a saying very early in my military career that made a lot of sense to me, and I think is in spirit with your original statement: "War is our business, but peace is our profession." As to McGibblet's statement, the military does not need to be at war to be kept occupied. Take my branch for instance. The Air Force has been continuously operating in the Middle Eastern theater for over 20 years. 10 of those years were during peace time enforcing no fly zones in Iraq and providing military and humanitarian airlift throughout the region.
McGibblets January 17, 2013 at 12:21 PM
'"War is our business, but peace is our profession."' why can't peace be both your business and profession? 'As to McGibblet's statement, the military does not need to be at war to be kept occupied. Take my branch for instance. The Air Force has been continuously operating in the Middle Eastern theater for over 20 years. 10 of those years were during peace time enforcing no fly zones in Iraq and providing military and humanitarian airlift throughout the region."' Occupying another country or zone for 20 years outside of our borders is not peace nor is it support for our troops. If you support troops then bring them home so they can occupy their own homes and families. 18% more troops died from SUICIDE than in combat last year.... why would anyone support that?
McGibblets January 17, 2013 at 12:41 PM
'1) Progressive in the sense of expecting and aligning ourselves with long term trends. I consider this a pragmatic rather than ethical choice. I think both conservatives and liberals can be progressives.' Thats not progressive thats just living life, we all (as in rational beings) make decisions to better our situation and better prepare for the future together or as a whole, thats not progressivism, thats life. Aligning ourselves with long term trends? they arent trends if we arent already aligning with them, they're outliers. You can consider it a pragmatic or ethical choice, im indifferent, you can call it pragmatic ethics for all i care you've still failed to justify it. As far as military, see below. Supporting military blindly without regard to their occupation provided in your eyes its not 'war' is both arrogant and ignorant. If you claimed you supported defense and not imperialism that would mean something completely different and then maybe we could be 'frenemeies'.
McGibblets January 17, 2013 at 12:41 PM
"3) “Public Service” as in those professions that make up “civil society.” My ambivalence is because while I believe the right to organize is an essential to democratic society I don’t feel the same way about tenure" While I certainly wont argue with you about tenure, as im eager to read your future writings regarding your distaste for it I do find conflict with your 'public servant' example. Define 'civli society' because the nice lady that works at my local 7/11 surely contributes to civil society facilitating transactions among people who have money and want to buy something but surely people dont view her as a public servant. Public service is a sham, if you taught in a private school is it public service or is it only public if its a public school? '4) Meat has become the rule rather than the exception and this, from a strictly pragmatic viewpoint, is a less efficient way to produce food' -again, pragmatic, do you have points of view that are not pragmatic? Better yet, for clarity since you've used it several times, how about your definition of pragmatic or how you define the word in accordance with your use. You can harvest the grain to eat and consume without feeding the animal if you choose but to think its the answer is well, unsubstantiated. Let the cows pasture and produce their own natural methane or run your deisel burning tractors and machinery over thousands of acres so you can eat 'cleanly'? Naive.
McGibblets January 17, 2013 at 12:43 PM
"Objectivity is Dead. Long live Subjectivity." Nevermind, dont even bother....
Tommy Warshaw III January 17, 2013 at 12:45 PM
"why can't peace be both your business and profession?" Because the military, by nature is a fighting force. "Occupying another country or zone for 20 years outside of our borders is not peace..." Well, then we ascribe to different notions or definitions of peace then. As far as your trying to throw the suicide rate out there to garner an emotional rather than a logical response, that statistic doesn't even begin to tell the whole story and cannot solely be linked to any conflict. In fact, the CDC's report for military suicides from this past year lists that only 38% of those deceased had been deployed. That's hardly enough to point to the military being engaged as the culprit of an increase in suicides.
McGibblets January 17, 2013 at 12:51 PM
"Because the military, by nature is a fighting force." Not a war force, two different things... 'fight' for peace but does that mean drones, bombs, guns etc? sounds hypocritical to use violence to get peace or maybe that which 'you' or 'we' or whoever is fighting might not be worth the fight. 'Well, then we ascribe to different notions or definitions of peace then.' What arrogance to think that those countries are leaps and bounds more peaceful thanks to our occupation. If nothing they're littered with more dead bodies, more broken families and a shattered economy. Without mention of the regimes we put in place to 'free' the people. WooHoo chalk up a victory for peace! I threw the suicide rate out there because its REAL thats all, quite presumptions to think I give a damn about emotional responses. Unlike the author i think subjective is dead and long live objective. '"The VA estimates that an average of 18 veterans per day commit suicide, or 1 out of 5 suicides in the U.S. But that’s just a guess based on incomplete data, said Jan Kemp, who heads the VA’s suicide prevention programs. “To be honest, we don’t know how many veterans are dying by suicide,” Kemp said. “It’s too many, and we have to do whatever we can to stop it.”' Boy I hope we're getting a lot of 'peace' in return!
Chris W January 20, 2013 at 02:02 PM
This captures my thoughts on the subject. http://aero-stuff.com/b-52-peace-the-old-fashioned-way-vinyldecal-sticker-10quot-wide-1095-p-1363.html It's the idea of peace through strength. The world is but a reflection of its inhabitants and at times it seems like a school yard with most kids getting along, but one or two bullies flexing their muscles. Bullies only understand one thing. Hit them in the nose once in a while and they will likely keep their distance. Show weakness and they will harass you without end. I don't take issue with the "against war, but support the troops" mentality. The left has come a long way since Vietnam When they were against both war and the troops.
Barbara Dziedzic January 20, 2013 at 07:48 PM
I really appreciate your perspective and eloquence on this issue. I married into an Air Force family, and my Father-in-law's career has been characterized by his work supporting nations around the world during democratic transitions (which are commonly very messy). This work began while he was first in the military (in El Salvador), and then after he retired working with a number of different agencies (in Bosnia, and most recently Syria). His understanding of civil society and rule of law is rooted in the work he did while in the military. Thank you again for your service and for contributing your insights to this conversation.
McGibblets January 20, 2013 at 08:34 PM
"Thank you again for your service and for contributing your insights to this conversation." Anytime Barb, dont mention it.

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »